Christopher Smith Nov 15, 2026

 The Only Living Pickpocket In New York

On a day where a nor’easter slapped New York City like a cutscene from one of those “end of the world” Hollywood-scripted blockbusters, I got to check out a film that will godown as one of the best love letters to New York City as a main character in motion pictures ever made.

 

That movie? The Only Living Pickpocket In New York.

 

Sitting in Nitehawk Cinema’s theatre by Prospect Park West in Brooklyn with my friend Mola before the film began, I thought about how rainy afternoons in movie houses are one of those third spaces people are fighting to hold onto.AMC Kips Bay. Cinema 1-2-3. The multiplex on Jamaica Avenue. Theaters shutting down, or on the road to shutting down because studios feel they can’t (or don’t want to compete) with streaming services at home. That’s a whole other essay to write.

 

But that feeling of being pushed aside by change, technology and time is what we see in the story of Harry Lehman, a master pickpocket played by the great John Turturro. Harry is trying to survive with his, *ahem*, criminal art but is bumping into reminders that his old world is moving on without him in different ways. And he’s trying to survive, while takingcare of his catatonic wife, Rosie (Karina Arroyave, who you might remember from Lean On Me). 

 

And just when you think he’s caught a big score lifting the keys from some random young dude from Jersey named Dylan (Will Price) who moves like a know-it-all hipster you’ve seen waiting on lines for exclusive cookie releases or something like that, enabling him to get a wad of cash and a mysterious USB drive? That’s when things go left, swiftly like a vinyl record scratch. Dylan, who it turns out is connected to a “family” that’s unnamed, finds out where Harry lives and threatens to kill Rosie unless he gets back that USB card in six hours. We then see Harry making his move, all with the backdrop of the different boroughs of NYC, and confronting his past in moving and emotional ways.

 

Okay, first off - this is a movie that I plan to watch again and again for a few reasons. The way that director and screenwriter Noah Segan put this film together tapped into an inner dialogue that so many who came up in and around New York City has been having. If you can recite the “Milford Plaza”commercials, still call Fulton Street Mall “Albee Square”, can remember Tad’s Steaks, Cosby Sporting Goods, ran home from school to watch “Yo! MTV Raps” and “Video Music Box” and “Rap City” - you know that inner dialogue. There’s one scene where I flipped hearing “Native New Yorker” by Mirror Image playing. CLASSIC DISCO. 

 

Segan’s usage of the city as a character brought me back to older movies that did the same, especially noir classics such as Samuel Fuller’s Pickup On South Street, and Martin Scorcese’s Mean Streets and even Brian de Palma’s Carlito’s Way. The shots of Harry on the subway are so well-framed; I have to highlight Harry’s first conversation with Detective Warren, played by another great actor, Giancarlo Esposito. It’s a riveting, not too tense dialogue between two men who are feeling the same push of life changing around them. It could’ve been held anywhere else like a street corner or diner booth, but to have it on the subway that runs 24 hours a day was significant. And both men emote so well. 

 

Turturro hasn’t been the lead in a film in two decades before taking on the role of Harry Lehman. From the first moments you see him on screen, you see the jovial stance, the hustling mind. But you also see the reserved sadness, the lines of regret. The things he couldn’t bring himself to say. That gets highlighted more in his one scene with Tatiana Maslany in the film. The way that Turturro pulls at your heartstrings one way as Maslany’s fury and sadness rips into him, and how he takes it without replying - I didn’t hear any sound at all in the theater for that whole scene, it was that gripping.

 

Mola and I raved about the film over a beer at a new brew pub down the block, which for years was a laundromat called the Wash Inn. We both weighed the impact of what we saw, and found some irony being in that space with a carefully selected beer menu and an interior that felt like it was a mancave in someone’s suburban estate in Sweden with all of the polishedpine. A nice spot, but definitely different than what you’d see in Park Slope.

 

It brought me back to the character of Dylan, who the moment he gets on scene you’ll recognize IMMEDIATELY. A whole lot of cleverness cloaked in pretentious swagger. He sits in contrast to Eve (Victoria Moroles), the sweet hacker grandaughter of Harry’s friend and fence, Ben (played by the veteran Steve Buscemi), who is in the same age bracket as Dylan but definitely is the opposite of him in demeanor and maturity.

 

Consider this - Turturro and Esposito are reunited in this film,decades after their roles in Spike Lee’s iconic Do The Right Thing. Esposito spoke about the power of their friendship and working relationship in an interview, noting how the two nearly broke down during filming one pivotal scene. (Check it out here.)

 

Another thing that grabbed me were the little moments harkening back to the old New York City, like one scene where Harry gets off the subway and goes to make a call at a payphone. Read that again - a PAYPHONE. Like, how did he even know how to find one?!!!! Also. 

 

The Only Living Pickpocket In New York will make you think about how much we cope with change, and how much we salvage - or don’t - to move forward with life. Only thing I have left to say is, go see it - and put me down for a copy when Criterion releases their DVD.

 

 

 

 

SHARE

Football, Dive Bars and Burgers On Frenchmen Street